loaded potato salad is the thing I make when I want everyone to stop hovering around the grill and actually eat something. You know the situation: people are hungry, the burgers are still a few minutes away, and someone always asks, “Is there a side dish?” This is that side dish. It’s creamy, a little smoky, and it has that baked potato vibe with all the good stuff mixed right in. I’ve brought it to potlucks where I barely got a spoonful before it disappeared. And yes, it’s the one people text about later asking, “What did you put in that?”

Should I boil or roast the potatoes for this recipe?

I’ve done it both ways, and I’ll be honest: you can make a great bowl either way. But the vibe changes depending on what you choose.

If you boil the potatoes, you’ll get a softer, classic potato salad texture. It’s faster, it’s familiar, and it’s easy to control if you keep an eye on them. The downside is that boiled potatoes can drink up water, and if you overcook them by even a couple minutes, they go from “tender” to “oops, mashed.”

If you roast them (or bake them like baked potatoes), the flavor is deeper and a little more earthy. You get those slightly dry, fluffy insides that soak up dressing in a really good way. It also helps the potatoes hold their shape, which matters when you want the salad to look hearty instead of mushy.

So what do I recommend? If you have the time, go with roasted or baked. If you’re rushing for a weeknight dinner, boiling is totally fine. Either way, let the potatoes cool a bit before mixing so you don’t end up with warm mayo soup.

One more practical tip: whichever method you use, try to keep the potato pieces similar in size. That way, you won’t have some chunks falling apart while others are still kind of firm.

Whats Needed for Loaded Potato Salad?

This is where the “loaded” part earns its keep. Think of everything you’d pile onto a baked potato, then imagine it all hanging out together in one bowl.

My go to ingredients

Potatoes: I like russet for that baked potato feel, but Yukon gold works too if you want a creamier bite.
Bacon: cooked until crisp, then chopped.
Cheddar cheese: sharp cheddar gives the best punch.
Sour cream: this is the signature tang.
Mayonnaise: just enough to make it creamy, not heavy.
Green onions: for freshness and that little zip.
Salt and black pepper: don’t skip the pepper, it matters here.

You can also add little extras if you’re feeling it. A spoon of Dijon mustard is great for a subtle bite. A tiny pinch of garlic powder can make it taste like you tried harder than you did. And if you like heat, a few chopped pickled jalapenos are honestly amazing.

One thing I’ll say from experience: shred your own cheese if you can. Bagged shredded cheese works, but it doesn’t melt or blend as nicely because of the coating. Not a deal breaker, just a nice upgrade when you have time.

How to Make Baked Potatoes for Potato Salad

If you want that true loaded potato salad flavor, baked potatoes are the move. This is the method I reach for when I’m bringing it somewhere and want people to be impressed, even though it’s still very doable.

Simple baked potato method (no fancy steps)

First, heat your oven to 400 F. Scrub your potatoes well because yes, we’re keeping the skins on for extra flavor and that rustic look. Dry them off, then poke a few holes with a fork so they don’t puff up and act dramatic in the oven.

Rub the skins lightly with oil and sprinkle with salt. This is the tiny step that makes the skins taste good instead of chewy and bland.

Bake until a fork slides in easily, usually 45 to 60 minutes depending on size. If your potatoes are huge, it’ll take longer. Let them cool until they’re comfortable to handle, then cut into bite size chunks.

Here’s my personal trick: after chopping, I spread the potato pieces on a tray for 10 minutes so steam can escape. This keeps the dressing from getting watery later. It’s a small thing, but it helps.

Once the potatoes are just warm or room temp, toss them with a pinch of salt and pepper right away. Potatoes love seasoning, and doing it early makes the whole salad taste better.

Tips for the Best Loaded Potato Salad

I’ve made this enough times to know where it can go wrong, and thankfully it’s easy to avoid the common issues.

Little details that make a big difference

Don’t mix it piping hot. Warm potatoes are fine, but hot potatoes melt everything and turn the texture weird. Let them cool down a bit.

Cook bacon until truly crisp. If it’s chewy, it gets kind of sad once it sits in the creamy dressing. I save a little bacon for the top so it stays crunchy.

Balance the creamy stuff. I like a mix of sour cream and mayo. Sour cream gives tang, mayo gives smoothness. If you go all sour cream, it can taste sharp. If you go all mayo, it can feel heavy.

Season in layers. Salt the potatoes, then taste again after mixing. Cheese and bacon add salt, so it’s better to adjust at the end than to overdo it early.

Let it chill. Give it at least 1 to 2 hours in the fridge if you can. The flavors settle down and it tastes more “together.”

Save toppings for the end. A sprinkle of extra cheddar, green onions, and bacon right before serving makes it look fresh and gives you better texture.

And if you’re making this for a cookout, keep it cold. I set the bowl inside a bigger bowl filled with ice if it’s sitting out for a while. It’s not just a food safety thing, it also keeps it tasting better.

;

What To Serve With Potato Salad

This is one of those sides that can handle a lot. It’s rich, so it pairs best with simple, savory mains or anything off the grill.

Burgers or cheeseburgers, especially with grilled onions
Hot dogs or sausages with mustard
BBQ chicken, ribs, or pulled pork
Grilled veggies like corn, zucchini, and peppers
Simple salads like cucumber and tomato to balance the richness

If I’m doing a backyard spread, I’ll put loaded potato salad next to something crunchy like coleslaw, and something bright like watermelon or a citrusy fruit salad. It just makes the whole plate feel less heavy.

Also, don’t underestimate it as a “meal prep lunch” situation. Add a little extra protein like chopped chicken or even a couple hard boiled eggs, and it turns into a real lunch that actually keeps you full.

Common Questions

Can I make loaded potato salad the night before?
Yes, and it’s honestly better the next day. Just save a bit of bacon, cheese, and green onion to sprinkle on top right before serving.

Do I have to keep the potato skins on?
Nope. I like the skins because they make it taste more like a baked potato, but you can peel them if you want a smoother, more classic texture.

How long can it sit out at a cookout?
I try not to leave it out longer than 1 to 2 hours, less if it’s really hot outside. I usually set the bowl over ice so it stays cold and creamy.

What if my potato salad feels dry after chilling?
That happens sometimes because potatoes soak up dressing as they sit. Stir in a spoonful of sour cream or mayo, and add a tiny splash of milk if you need it looser.

Can I lighten it up?
You can swap in Greek yogurt for part of the sour cream, and use less cheese and bacon. It’ll still taste good, just a little less “loaded.”

Final thoughts before you make it

If you take anything from this, let it be this: don’t rush the cooling step, and taste as you go. That’s what keeps loaded potato salad from turning into a bland bowl of potatoes with stuff in it. When it’s done right, it tastes like your favorite loaded baked potato, but easier to share and way more scoopable.

And if you like comparing recipes like I do, it’s worth checking out Loaded Baked Potato Salad – Southern Bite. I love seeing how other home cooks build their versions, and it’s a nice reminder that there’s no one perfect way, as long as it tastes amazing.

Now go grab a spoon before everyone else does.

Loaded Potato Salad

Author: grace
Total Time: 75 minutes
Yield: 8 servings 1x
Diet: Vegetarian

Print Recipe

Description

Creamy, smoky Loaded Potato Salad that combines all the flavors of a baked potato in a hearty dish.

Instructions

Preheat oven to 400°F (200°C).
Scrub potatoes and poke holes with a fork, then rub with oil and sprinkle with salt.
Bake for 45 to 60 minutes until fork-tender. Let cool.
Cut potatoes into bite-sized chunks and spread on a tray to let steam escape.
Toss potatoes with salt and pepper while still warm.
In a large bowl, combine potatoes, bacon, cheddar cheese, sour cream, mayonnaise, and green onions. Mix thoroughly.
Season to taste and let chill for at least 1 to 2 hours before serving.
Top with additional bacon, cheese, and green onions right before serving.